PJM, FERC Focus on Large Load Challenges at Tech Conference

152

PJM joined industry leaders Wednesday to discuss the novel and significant operating and planning challenges associated with the accelerating growth and energy use patterns of data centers.

Mounting supply concerns caused by the demand growth from these large load customers, combined with the lag in development of new generation and transmission facilities required to serve them, were the focus of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s annual Reliability Technical Conference Oct. 21.

Rising Tide of Near Constant Power Usage

PJM’s Christopher Pilong, PJM Sr. Director – Operations Planning, brought a system operator perspective to the first panel, “The State of Reliability in a Changing Energy Landscape – Operational Challenges of Integrating Large Loads in Evolving System Dynamics.”

Unlike traditional, seasonal or time-of-day demand patterns, data centers’ nearly constant energy consumption makes it more challenging to maintain reliability during the spring and fall “shoulder” seasons, when generation and transmission owners traditionally take their equipment out of service to perform facility maintenance and upgrades.

“It really is like a rising sea level,” Pilong told FERC commissioners Wednesday. “It is every hour of the day.”

When large portions of generation capacity and transmission facilities are offline, conditions may give rise to emergency procedures to maintain reliability. This occurred Oct. 12–14, when hot weather up to 20 degrees above normal affected PJM and grid operators to the west and south.

“Two to three years ago, we would not have seen that,” Pilong stated Wednesday. Until new generation and transmission facilities come online, operational flexibility and emergency procedures will continue to be required to maintain reliability, he added. “It really is about getting things built.”

Call for Large Load Transparency and Coordination

Pilong detailed four reliability priorities springing from the mismatch between the speed of large-load development and needed construction of generation and transmission. In his prefiled statement (PDF) filed at FERC, Pilong said PJM supports a reliability framework that:

  • Requires timely, accurate and continuously updated technical information from large load operators
  • Establishes enforceable voltage and frequency ride-through requirements for both new and existing large loads
  • Ensures that interconnection and energization decisions reflect time required to develop sufficient generation and transmission
  • Advances coordinated electric-gas planning, cybersecurity protections and accountability for facility performance

Keeping the Grid Dependable During Data Center Load Transfers

PJM is exploring how to make sure that large loads safely connect to the grid, provide information on inverter-based models and settings, log incident data, and report on performance.

Toward this end, PJM is developing voltage and frequency ride-through requirements informed by events on July 22, when about 3,900 MW of large loads unexpectedly and inadvertently transferred to backup generation in response to routine transmission events.

This unexpected disruption, in response to routine transmission events, was managed by PJM and transmission owners but caused concerning voltage fluctuations. Incidents like these highlight the need for data center ride-through requirements to establish standards and thresholds at which facilities must remain connected to the grid, rather than disconnecting and threatening system stability.

In addition to its own work in this area, PJM is participating in North American Electric Reliability Corp. efforts to draft standards for Large Computational Loads.

Besides managing ride-through coordination, the prospects of coordinated, malicious acts remain a threat to reliability. Those risks further support proactive development of system controls, incident reporting obligations, operational coordination and recovery requirements.

Exploring Data Center Flexibility

FERC Commissioners and participants discussed frameworks whereby systematic routines and communication channels would enable grid operators, transmission owners, state regulators and data centers to synchronize operations to maintain reliability.

One example discussed was PJM’s work with Emerald AI and other data center customers to explore how to reduce power usage and potential impacts to residential customers via reductions in data center energy usage for certain computational jobs. These practices, known as “compute flexibility,” either are being or will be studied at multiple data centers across the PJM service area, including an NVIDIA AI factory in Manassas, Virginia.

In addition, PJM is working on its response to FERC’s call for development of interim, or non-firm, transmission service frameworks, Pilong said. Reform like this may enable the kind of operations coordination that exists between PJM’s Control Room and the owners of generation and transmission assets, he added.

“Today, we have entities we work with where we know if we give them an operating instruction, they will be able to follow it,” he said. PJM will need that same level of response and flexibility from data centers while transmission and generation catches up with demand, he added.

“That is the direction we need to move in,” Pilong said. “There is no other solution.”